Showing posts with label William J Murnane. Show all posts
Showing posts with label William J Murnane. Show all posts
Posted by Kate Phizackerley on Sunday, October 24, 2010

The Nefertiti bust has been in the blogs again with Andie Byrnes reporting that 1.2 million people viewed it last year.  So we know what Nefertiti looked like.

Or do we?  I mentioned the papers written in memorial to Bill Murnane some time ago, but I am still working through them.  I recommend the paper by Earl L Ertman on the Images of Amenhotep IV and Nefertiti in the Style of the Previous Reign [Amenhotep III].  Relatively few images of Nefertiti have been identified from the reign of Amenhotep III (or perhaps more precisely, few images showing pre-Amarnan styling), but Ertman still charts changes in the representation of Nefertiti.  The changes in the representation of Akhenaten are well known, but less has been written on the changes in the representation of Queen Nefertiti.  Comparing the images in the paper with the famous bust, there are clear differences for example in the shape of the eyes.  While it is tempting to assume that the bust is a photographic representation of Nefertiti, there are grounds for feeling that Amarna era images are more stylised that faithful portraits.

The portrayal of royalty is often not accurate.  Even portaits of HM Queen Elizabeth are remarkably varied and, in candour, some do not especially look like her Majesty.  In Medieval England portraits of English queens often depicted them with blonde hair because that we the popular feminine ideal, even though they are now known to have had dark hair (for instance some Spanish princesses).

There is no doubt that the bust is a wonderful piece of art, but it may still be an idealised representation.

Posted by Kate Phizackerley on Sunday, July 11, 2010

Marianne Luban linked Causing His Name to Live: Studies in Egyptian Epigraphy and History in Memory of William J. Murnane in one of her recent comments.  As the page says:

William J. Murnane (1945-2000) dedicated his life to the epigraphic recording and historical interpretation of the monuments of pharaonic Egypt. In tribute to his important contributions to Egyptology, a prominent group of his colleagues and students offer a range of new studies on Egyptian epigraphy and historiography. Amarna studies loom large in the volume as they did in Murnane's own work.
I've just started going through the papers and there is some great stuff linked there.  It's going to take me to read it all (and there's more in the same thread of comments that I need to read and appreciate as well).  I've started with James Allen's paper on the Amarna Succession.

If you haven't seen this collection of papers before, then I really do suggest that you take a look.  My thanks to Marianne.

Search

Admin Control Panel